Meghna Desai Thilo Rehren


Pre-industrial crucible steel ingots, produced in both Central and South Asia, are an important class of iron-carbon alloys. Their microstructure reflects their formation from a liquid alloy at a carbon content of 1.0–2.5wt%, which is higher than most mild steels but lower than most cast irons. This article introduces a tool to quantify the carbon content of such alloys based on an operator-supervised image analysis which determines the relative proportions of austenite/pearlite and cementite, respectively, from high-contrast back-scatter electron images of unetched samples. Using examples from a recently discovered hoard of crucible steel ingots in Telangana, south-central India, we demonstrate the capabilities of the tool and test its usefulness. The main benefit is in improving accuracy and precision in metallography-based carbon content determination in such alloys by reducing the uncertainty in area estimation in complex microstructures based on visual impression alone.


Alaa N and Abidne El I Z 2021, Image processing with Python: An introduction. LAMAI Laboratory FST, Cadi Ayyad University (Marrakech).
Czarski A, Skowronek T, and Matusiewicz P 2015, ‘Stability of a lamellar structure – effect of the true interlamellar spacing on the durability of a pearlite colony’, Archives of Metallurgy and Materials 60, 2499–2503.
Das G 1999, ‘Image analysis in quantitative metallography’ in G Sridhar, S Ghosh Chowdhuny and N G Goswami (eds), Materials characterization techniques, principles and applications (NML Jamshedpur), 135–150.
Doane D and Seward LE 2011, ‘Measuring skewness: A forgotten statistic?’ Journal of Statistics Education 19(2).
Ferrer-Eres M A, Peris-Vicente J, Valle-Algarra F M, Gimeno-Adelantado J V, Sanchez-Ramos S, and Soriano-Pinol M D 2010, ‘Archaeopolymetallurgical study of materials from an Iberian culture site in Spain by scanning electron microscopy with X-ray microanalysis, chemometrics and image analysis,’ Microchemical Journal 95, 298–305.
Jaikishan S, Desai M, Rehren T 2021, ‘A journey of over 200 years: early studies on wootz ingots and new evidence from Konasamudram, India,’ Advances in Archaeomaterials 2(1), 15–23.
Maritan L, Piovesan R, Dal Sasso G, Baklouti S, Casas L, Mazzoli C, Salmoso L, and Corain L 2020, ‘Comparison between different image acquisition methods for grain-size analysis and quantification of ceramic inclusions by digital image processing: how much similar are the results?’ Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences 12, 167.
Reedy C, Anderson J, Reedy T, and Liu Y 2014, ‘Image analysis in quantitative particle studies of archaeological ceramic thin sections,’ Advances in Archaeological Practice 2, 252–268.
Rehren T and Hauptmann A 1994, ‘Römische Eisenblöcke von der Saalburg: Untersuchungen zur Fertigungstechnik’ Saalburg-Jahrbuch 47, 79–85.
Scott D A 1991, Metallography and microstructure of ancient and historic metals (Marina del Rey, CA).
Scott D A 2013, Ancient metals: Microstructure and metallurgy Vol IV: Iron and steel (Los Angeles, CA).
Vander Voort G 2015, ‘Introduction to quantitative metallography’, Tech Notes 1(5).
Wayman M L and Juleff G 1999, ‘Crucible steelmaking in Sri Lanka,’ Historical Metallurgy 33(1), 26–42.
How to Cite
Estimating carbon content in crucible steel using image analysis. (2023). Historical Metallurgy, 54(2), in print.