Thilo Rehren Karsten Hess Graham Philip

Abstract

Among the early silver artefacts known from Egypt and the Near East, there is a large group of objects composed of silver bearing up to 30, even 50 wt% gold. The composition of two fragments from silver artefacts excavated in fourth millennium BC contexts at Tell esh-Shuna in northem Jordan relates them to this auriferous group. A review of traditional ideas conceming early west Asian silver, in the light of recent analytical data from both artefactual and geological sources, indicates that some reconsideration is required. The oft-cited suggestion, initially made by Lucas (1928), that there existed exploitation of silver-dorninated placer deposits in ancient Egypt, seems a less convincing explanation for the compositional pattems detectable in ancient silver artefacts than alternatives such as mixing as a result of recycling.

##plugins.themes.bootstrap3.article.details##

Keywords
References
Bayley J and Eckstein K (1996) 'Silver Refining - Production, Recycling, Assaying', in A Sinclair et al (eds), Archaeological Sciences 1995 (Oxford) 113-117.
Becker L, Pilosi L and Schorsch B (1994) 'An Egyptian Silver Statuette of the Saite Period - A Technical Study', Metropolitan Museum Journal 29, 37-56.
Conrad S and Rehren Th ( 1996) "The silver mummy mask from Hildesheim: Restoration or conservation?' in K Barakat and J Merkel (eds), Ancient Egyptian Mining and Metallurgy and Conservation of Metallic Artefacts.
Gale N and Stos-Gale Z (1981) 'Ancient Egyptian Silver', Journal of Egyptian Archaeology 67, 103-115.
Graham A K (1929) 'Scientific Notes on the Finds from Ur, I: Restoration of the Silver', Museum Journal 20(3/4), 246-253.
Harrison T P ( 1993) 'Econornics with an Entrepreneurial Spirit: Early Bronze Age Trade with Late Predynastic Egypt', Biblical Archaeologist 56, 81-93.
Hauptmann A, Begemann F, Heitkemper E, Pernicka E and Schmitt-Strecker S ( 1992) 'Early Copper Produced at Feinan, Wadi Arabah, Jordan: The Composition of Ores and Copper', Archeomaterials 6, 1-33.
Hedges R E M ( 1976) 'On the Occurrence of Bromine in Corroded Silver ', Studies in Conservation 21, 44-46.
Hume W (1937) Geology of Egypt, Vol 2, Part 3 (Cairo).
Klemm D and Klemm R ( 1989) 'Antike Goldgewinnung in der Ostwüste Ägyptens', in A Hauptmann, E Pernicka and G Wagner (eds) Old World Archaeometallurgy (Der Anschnitt Beiheft 7) (Bochum), 227-234.
Klemm R and Klemm D (1994) 'Chronologischer Abriß der antiken Goldgewinnung in der Ostwüste Ägyptens', Mitt Deutsch Arch Inst Kairo SO, 189-222, T29-35.
Kohlmeyer K ( 1994) 'Zur frühen Geschichte von Blei und Silber', in R Wartke (ed) Handwerk und Technologie im Alten Orient (Mainz), 41-45.
Krupp R and Weiser T (1992) 'On the stability of gold-silver alloys in the weathering environment', Mineral. Deposita 27, 268-275.
Lechtman H ( 1971) 'Ancient Methods of Gilding Silver: Examples from the old and the New Worlds, in R Brill (ed) Science and Archaeology (Cambridge, Mass), 2-30.
Levy T E, van den Brink E C M, Goren Y and Alon D (1995) 'New Light on King Narmer and the Protodynastic Egyptian Presence in Canaan', Biblical Archaeologist 58, 26-35.
Lucas A (1928) 'Silver in ancient times', Journal of Egyptian Archaeology 14, 313-319.
Lucas A and Harris J (1962) Ancient Egyptian Materials and Industries (London).
Mishara J and Meyers P (1974) 'Ancient Egyptian silver: a review', in A Bishay (ed) Science and Technology of Materials III, 29-45.
Möller P (1995) 'Electrochemical corrosion of natural gold alloys', in G Morteani and P Northover (eds) Prehistoric Gold in Europe (Dordrecht), 357-367.
Morteani G (1995) 'Mineral economics, mineralogy, geochemistry and structure of gold deposits: An overview', in G Morteani and P Northover (eds) Prehistoric Gold in Europe (Dordrecht), 97-113.
Moorey P R S (1994) Ancient Mesopotamian Materials and lndustries. The Archaeological Evidence (Oxford).
Oddy A (1993) "The assaying of gold by touchstone in antiquity and the medieval world', in C Eluere ( ed) Outils et ateliers d' orfevres des temps anciens (Saint-Germain-enLaye ), 93-100.
Pernicka E, Wagner G, Assimenos K, Doumas Ch, Begemann F and Todt W (1982) 'An Analytical Study of Prehistoric Lead and Silver Objects from the Aegean', in Proceedings of the 22nd Symposium on Archaeometry (Bradford), 292-302.
Pernicka E and Wagner G (1985) 'Die metallurgische Bedeutung von Sifnos im Altertum', in G Wagner and G Weisgerber (eds) Silber, Blei und Gold auf Sifnos, (Der Anschnitt Beiheft 3) (Bochum), 200-211.
Philip G and Baird D (1993) 'Preliminary Report on the Second (1992) Season of Excavations at Tell esh-Shuna North', Levant 25, 13-36.
Philip G and Rehren Th (1996) 'Fourth millennium BC silver from Tell esh-Shuna, Jordan: Archaeometallurgical investigation and some thoughts on ceramic skeuomorphs', Oxford Journal of Archaeology 15, 129-150.
Prag K (1978) 'Silver in the Levant in the Fourth Millennium B.C. ', in PR S Moorey and P J Parr (eds) Archaeology in the Levant: Essays for Kathleen Kenyon (Warminster), 36-45.
Ramdohr P (1980) The Ore Minerals and Their Intergrowths (Oxford).
Rapson W ( 1990) 'The Metallurgy of the Coloured Carat Gold Alloys', Gold Bulletin 23, 125-133.
Rösler H and Lange H (1976) Geochemische Tabellen (Stuttgart).
Schneiderhöhn H (1962) Erzlagerstätten (Stuttgart).
Shalev S and Northover P (1993) 'The Metallurgy of the Nahal Mishmar Hoard reconsidered', Archaeometry 35, 35-47.
Stos-Gale Z, Gale N and Houghton J (1995) 'The Origins of Egyptian Copper: Lead-Isotope Analysis of Metals from El Amarna', in V Davies and L Schofield (eds) Egypt, the Aegean and the Levant (London), 127-135.
Tadmor M, Kedem D, Begemann F, Hauptmann A, Pemicka E and Schmitt-Strecker S (1995) 'The Nahal Mishmar Hoard from the Jud~an Desert: Technology, Composition, and Provenance', Atiqot 27, 95-148.
How to Cite
Auriferous Silver in Western Asia: Ore or alloy?. (2022). Historical Metallurgy, 30(1), 1-10. https://www.hmsjournal.org/index.php/home/article/view/424
Section
Articles